Hometrino is now on iOS & Android — download the app for the best experience.

App StoreGoogle Play

Homes for Sale in Sumterville, FL 33585

1–40 of 40 results

1359 Darren Dr, THE VILLAGES, FL 34762
Active
Stellar MLS
$499,000
Single Family Residence
3 bd • 2 ba • 1,497 sq ft
1359 Darren Dr, THE VILLAGES, FL 34762
REALTY EXECUTIVES IN THE VILLAGES
7462 Savanna Dr, THE VILLAGES, FL 32163
Active
Stellar MLS
$324,500
Single Family Residence
2 bd • 2 ba • 1,134 sq ft
7462 Savanna Dr, THE VILLAGES, FL 32163
WORTH CLARK REALTY
7778 Brian Etheredge Way, THE VILLAGES, FL 34762
Active
Stellar MLS
$799,000
Single Family Residence
3 bd • 2 ba • 1,953 sq ft
7778 Brian Etheredge Way, THE VILLAGES, FL 34762
RE/MAX PREMIER REALTY
2342 Oklahoma Dr, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
Pending
Stellar MLS
$315,990
Single Family Residence
4 bd • 3 ba • 1,941 sq ft
2342 Oklahoma Dr, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
WJH BROKERAGE FL LLC
2748 Cr 543, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
Pending
Stellar MLS
$324,900
Single Family Residence
2 bd • 1 ba • 1,008 sq ft
2748 Cr 543, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
SAVVY AVENUE, LLC
7528 Daniel Collins Ct, THE VILLAGES, FL 34762
Active
Stellar MLS
$679,470
Single Family Residence
3 bd • 2 ba • 1,927 sq ft
7528 Daniel Collins Ct, THE VILLAGES, FL 34762
SALLY LOVE REAL ESTATE
7634 Frank Dipietro Dr, THE VILLAGES, FL 34762
Active
Stellar MLS
$1,070,000
Single Family Residence
3 bd • 2 ba • 1,959 sq ft
7634 Frank Dipietro Dr, THE VILLAGES, FL 34762
SALLY LOVE REAL ESTATE
1539 SE 34th Way, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
Active
Stellar MLS
$860,000
Single Family Residence
3 bd • 2 ba • 1,756 sq ft
1539 SE 34th Way, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
PEGASUS REALTY & ASSOC INC
2242 Cr 543, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
Active
Stellar MLS
$619,000
Single Family Residence
3 bd • 2 ba • 1,565 sq ft
2242 Cr 543, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
REAL BROKER, LLC
1586 Texas Ave, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
Active
Stellar MLS
$329,900
Single Family Residence
4 bd • 3 ba • 2,240 sq ft
1586 Texas Ave, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
GAILEY ENTERPRISES REAL ESTATE
1746 Nebraska Loop, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
Active
Stellar MLS
$270,000
Single Family Residence
3 bd • 2 ba • 1,263 sq ft
1746 Nebraska Loop, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
FLORIDA REALTY INVESTMENTS
2231 Cr 543, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
Pending
Stellar MLS
$400,000
Single Family Residence
4 bd • 2 ba • 1,955 sq ft
2231 Cr 543, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
SMITH & SMITH REALTY, INC.
1724 S Us 301, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
Pending
Stellar MLS
$106,000
Single Family Residence
3 bd • 1 ba • 884 sq ft
1724 S Us 301, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
BEYCOME OF FLORIDA LLC
1876 Iowa Dr, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
Active
Stellar MLS
$244,900
Single Family Residence
3 bd • 2 ba • 1,265 sq ft
1876 Iowa Dr, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
CENTRAL CITY REALTY
2372 Oklahoma Dr, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
Pending
Stellar MLS
$341,990
Single Family Residence
5 bd • 3 ba • 2,277 sq ft
2372 Oklahoma Dr, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
WJH BROKERAGE FL LLC
7262 Middleton Dr, MIDDLETON, FL 34762
Pending
Stellar MLS
$389,900
Single Family Residence
3 bd • 2 ba • 1,480 sq ft
7262 Middleton Dr, MIDDLETON, FL 34762
REALTY EXCHANGE, LLC
7442 Savanna Dr, THE VILLAGES, FL 34762
Active
Stellar MLS
$359,900
Single Family Residence
3 bd • 2 ba • 1,537 sq ft
7442 Savanna Dr, THE VILLAGES, FL 34762
CENTURY 21 ALTON CLARK
1582 S Us 301, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
Active
Stellar MLS
$450,000
Single Family Residence
1 bd • 1 ba • 500 sq ft
1582 S Us 301, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
FLAMINGO REAL ESTATE & MNGMT
879 Cr 539, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
Active
Stellar MLS
$820,000
Single Family Residence
5 bd • 5 ba • 3,088 sq ft
879 Cr 539, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
MORRIS REALTY AND INVESTMENTS
2300 Oklahoma Dr, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
Pending
Stellar MLS
$259,990
Single Family Residence
3 bd • 2 ba • 1,263 sq ft
2300 Oklahoma Dr, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
WJH BROKERAGE FL LLC
2291 SE 37th Rd, BUSHNELL, FL 33513
Active
Stellar MLS
$739,900
Single Family Residence
3 bd • 2 ba • 2,740 sq ft
2291 SE 37th Rd, BUSHNELL, FL 33513
RE/MAX TITANIUM GROUP
1565 Texas Ave, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
Active Under Contract
Stellar MLS
$260,000
Single Family Residence
3 bd • 2 ba • 1,303 sq ft
1565 Texas Ave, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
RE/MAX PREMIER REALTY
2327 Cr 528, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
Pending
Stellar MLS
$1,200,000
Single Family Residence
3 bd • 2 ba • 1,477 sq ft
2327 Cr 528, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
FLORIDA CAPITAL REALTY
2223 Cr 543, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
Active
Stellar MLS
$963,000
Single Family Residence
3 bd • 3 ba • 3,956 sq ft
2223 Cr 543, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
BHHS FLORIDA PROPERTIES GROUP
1638 Texas Ave, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
Active
Stellar MLS
$306,990
Single Family Residence
4 bd • 2 ba • 1,666 sq ft
1638 Texas Ave, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
WJH BROKERAGE FL LLC
2517 Oklahoma Dr, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
Active
Stellar MLS
$306,990
Single Family Residence
4 bd • 2 ba • 1,666 sq ft
2517 Oklahoma Dr, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
WJH BROKERAGE FL LLC
2366 Oklahoma Dr, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
Active
Stellar MLS
$303,990
Single Family Residence
4 bd • 2 ba • 1,666 sq ft
2366 Oklahoma Dr, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
WJH BROKERAGE FL LLC
2330 Oklahoma Dr, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
Active
Stellar MLS
$307,990
Single Family Residence
4 bd • 2 ba • 1,666 sq ft
2330 Oklahoma Dr, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
WJH BROKERAGE FL LLC
1634 Texas Ave, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
Active
Stellar MLS
$341,990
Single Family Residence
5 bd • 3 ba • 2,277 sq ft
1634 Texas Ave, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
WJH BROKERAGE FL LLC
2336 Oklahoma Dr, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
Active
Stellar MLS
$323,990
Single Family Residence
4 bd • 3 ba • 1,941 sq ft
2336 Oklahoma Dr, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
WJH BROKERAGE FL LLC
2360 Oklahoma Dr, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
Active
Stellar MLS
$323,990
Single Family Residence
4 bd • 3 ba • 1,941 sq ft
2360 Oklahoma Dr, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
WJH BROKERAGE FL LLC
2324 Oklahoma Dr, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
Active
Stellar MLS
$327,990
Single Family Residence
4 bd • 3 ba • 1,941 sq ft
2324 Oklahoma Dr, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
WJH BROKERAGE FL LLC
1295 N Us 301, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
Active
Stellar MLS
$435,000
Single Family Residence
2 bd • 3 ba • 1,424 sq ft
1295 N Us 301, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
CENTURY 21 PRIME PROPERTY RESOURCES INC
2318 Oklahoma Dr, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
Pending
Stellar MLS
$300,990
Single Family Residence
4 bd • 2 ba • 1,666 sq ft
2318 Oklahoma Dr, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
WJH BROKERAGE FL LLC
1170 Cr 543b, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
Active
Stellar MLS
$490,000
Single Family Residence
3 bd • 2 ba • 1,410 sq ft
1170 Cr 543b, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
DOWN HOME REALTY, LLLP
2312 Oklahoma Dr, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
Pending
Stellar MLS
$312,990
Single Family Residence
4 bd • 3 ba • 1,941 sq ft
2312 Oklahoma Dr, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
WJH BROKERAGE FL LLC
1674 Cadorette Dr, THE VILLAGES, FL 34762
Active
Stellar MLS
$455,000
Single Family Residence
3 bd • 2 ba • 1,696 sq ft
1674 Cadorette Dr, THE VILLAGES, FL 34762
FLORIDA IN MOTION REALTY INC
1763 Brody Ct, THE VILLAGES, FL 34762
Active
Stellar MLS
$269,000
Villa
2 bd • 2 ba • 984 sq ft
1763 Brody Ct, THE VILLAGES, FL 34762
KELLER WILLIAMS CORNERSTONE RE
7591 Mergaert Ln, MIDDLETON, FL 34762
Active
Stellar MLS
$470,000
Single Family Residence
4 bd • 2 ba • 2,061 sq ft
7591 Mergaert Ln, MIDDLETON, FL 34762
BEYCOME OF FLORIDA LLC
2059 Kentucky Rd, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
Active
Stellar MLS
$255,000
Single Family Residence
3 bd • 2 ba • 1,265 sq ft
2059 Kentucky Rd, SUMTERVILLE, FL 33585
JASON MITCHELL REAL ESTATE FLO

Data Powered by Home Junction, Inc.

ZIP 33585 local snapshot

Sumterville · Sumter County · FL

Population

1,424

Median household income

$80,972

Median home value

$213,900

Homeownership rate

84.5%

Housing tenure

Owner-occupied 84.5% · Renter-occupied 15.5%

84.5% own

Owner-occupiedRenter-occupied

How ZIP 33585 compares to Sumter County

Benchmarks use Census ACS data across 10 ZIP codes in Sumter County.

Median home value

15% below the county average
ZIP 33585$213,900
Sumter County average$251,600

Median household income

18% above the county average
ZIP 33585$80,972
Sumter County average$68,713

Homeownership rate

6% above the county average
ZIP 3358584.5%
Sumter County average80.0%

Nearby ZIP code comparison

See how ZIP 33585 stacks up against neighboring areas by median home value and income.

ZIPAreaMedian home valueMedian income
33585Sumterville$213,900$80,972
33521Coleman$99,500$55,455
33538Lake Panasoffkee$157,200$48,951
33514Center Hill$200,000$73,365
33513Bushnell$213,900$59,497
33597Webster$214,500$61,563

Source: U.S. Census Bureau ACS 5-year estimates · Data as of Sep 2026

Area profile

Population

7,484

Median household income

$70,265

Median home value

$332,197

Median age

59

Households

3,661

Owner occupied

86.1%

Renter occupied

13.9%

Typical year built

2000

High school

27.6%

Associate degree

10.2%

Bachelor's degree

24.2%

Graduate degree

12.4%

Recent sales in Sumterville, FL 33585

Homes sold (12 mo.)

2,204

Median sale price

$418,000

Median $/sq ft

$260/sq ft

33585, FL Housing Market Summary

Current MLS market statistics for active listings in this area.

Active listings40
New listings last 30 days7
Median list price$335,945
Median price per sq ft$221
List price range$259,999 - $824,000
Median bedrooms3
Median bathrooms2
Median living area1,666 sq ft
Typical HOA fees$263 – $270 / month